Key West Restaurants

A local favorite with a loyal following, Flamingo Crossing scoops up homemade ice cream in tropical flavors you won’t find anywhere else. The vibe is chill, the flavors are fresh, and the pink building is hard to miss.

Duetto is your go-to for a quick slice and a scoop in Old Town. They serve up crispy thin-crust pizza and creamy gelato made in-house daily. It’s casual, tasty, and perfect for a break between sightseeing stops.

Location: 540 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040
Website

For homemade Italian in a cozy setting, Mangia Mangia Pasta Cafe is a local favorite. Known for its fresh, house-made pasta and classic Italian flavors, this charming eatery is the perfect place for a comforting meal. Pair your pasta with a glass of wine, and enjoy the laid-back, welcoming atmosphere that makes every meal feel like home.

Location: 900 Southard St, Key West, FL 33040

Salute! On The Beach is a casual yet elegant beachside café combining fresh seafood with Italian and Caribbean flavors. Located on Higgs Beach, this local favorite is perfect for a laid-back lunch or romantic dinner with ocean views. The menu features everything from seafood pasta to Key West shrimp, and the open-air setting makes it a great place to soak up the salty breeze.